Instrumentation

As of 2015

Radiation tolerance of new detector technologies

Since 2007 we have led an ongoing radiation damage program at the LANSCE facility at Los Alamos National Laboratory. This effort is organized by Sally (who submits and defends proposals to a review panel at LANL) and Martin and involves all members of our group in biannual testbeam operations. Work at the beamline is followed by dosimetry and activation measurements and detailed study of radiation-induced modifications of device characteristics, all done by us in our UNM lab. The runs in September and December 2012, September 2013, February 2014, and October 2014 each involved approximately 100 unique prototypes. This work we do facilitates research by us and by scientists at 15 other institutes on ATLAS and CMS upgrades, RD42 diamond, RD53 readout chips, and RD50 silicon technologies. In our recent runs, the devices under test included silicon and diamond sensors, readout electronics chips and custom ASICs, VCSEL drivers, monolithic active pixel sensors, power supply switching elements, specialized cables, miniaturized peltier coolers, and upgrade calorimetry elements. In 2013 Haley and Martin added a customized system to provide vortex airflow cooling to silicon sensors undergoing temperature-critical annealing studies. Aidan is implementing a system of linear stages this year to allow us to scan larger devices in the beam. Igor developed the October 2014 run plan. Neil is taking over from Prabi the operation of our gamma spectrometer for nuclide activation measurements. We all take shifts and participate in device fixturing, assembly, and measurements. Our 2014 collaborative paper with UCSC derives from this effort. We propose to continue to lead LANSCE irradiations for the foreseeable future (at least through 2019) to promote technology developments for the LHC and other Energy Frontier applications.

We have developed a new method for real time measurement of charged particle beam profile and fluence. This technique was pioneered by Martin and implemented by Aaron (in software) and Prabi and Haley (in hardware). Aaron reported on it at DPF2013, and our NIM publication followed in 2014. We now use this diode array technique routinely in our Los Alamos irradiations. Neil updated the configuration this year to allow simultaneous readout of multiple arrays at different points in the stack of devices under test.

Sally coordinates on-demand irradiations of prototype detector technologies at the Sandia Annular Core Research Reactor (ACRR) and Gamma Irradiation Facility (GIF). This program was spearheaded by Sally and required over a year of negotiation of an Inter-Institutional Visitors Agreement between Sandia and UNM. In spring 2014 the GIF operators implemented a new radioactive source configuration specifically to provide uniform exposure to our large devices. In 2014 we applied the ACRR to about 20 tracking and calorimetry technologies requiring exposures from 1014 to a few times 1016 1-MeV-n-eq/cm2. We used the GIF especially for exposures of new pixel readout integrated circuit structures in our role as members of RD53. Martin collaborates with LBNL on this development of 65nm readout for future LHC pixel upgrades, and he is responsible for testing the transistors before and after GIF exposures.

New tracking sensor technologies in silicon and diamond

Martin, Nelly, and Sally are collaborating with Gian-Franco Dalla Betta of the University of Trento to improve the performance of silicon pixel sensors of the 3D geometry, which are used for particle tracking. "3D" differs from traditional planar silicon processing by orienting the electrodes perpendicularly to the wafer surface, permitting much smaller inter-electrode spacing. The result is lower depletion voltage, faster charge collection, and thus generally higher radiation tolerance. This technology, already in the ATLAS-IBL baseline, may meet even more critical needs at future hadron colliders. We measure the leakage current, capacitance, breakdown voltage, and charge collection efficiency of several design variations related to the electrode column structure. We recently published first measurements on proton-irradiated devices as "Characterization of New FBK Double-Sided 3D Sensors with Improved Breakdown Voltage". During 2014 we exposed samples of a further evolved design to gammas and neutrons at Sandia as well as high fluence protons at Los Alamos. We are preparing a paper on the results, for submission to JINST approximately November 2014. Nelly's honors thesis research will investigate 3D design options that are tolerant beyond 2 x 1016 1-MeV-n-eq/cm2.

Diamond is another sensor substrate option with potential for extreme radiation hardness in future particle tracking applications. During the period 2012-2014, Rui, Martin, and Sally carried out a study of the resistivity of polycrystalline diamond sensors as a function of temperature and charged particle fluence. Any effect of radiation on the resistivity propagates to the leakage current and could influence assessments of the material properties that depend on leakage current, such as active volume and charge collection distance. This is relevant to contemporary implementations of diamond detectors (including luminosity monitors at the LHC) as well as options for inner volume particle tracking in the future. Our 2014 paper reports no resistivity degradation up to fluences relevant to the HL-LHC. Sally presented "Recent Results on Diamond Radiation Tolerance" at IPRD2013.

Haley, Rui, and Martin conducted a study of the effect of humidity on reverse breakdown in silicon sensors of the 3D geometry, as a function of radiation damage up to fluences relevant to the HL-LHC. Reverse breakdown becomes an increasingly important parameter as detectors age and bias voltages must be raised to maintain adequate signal size. While humidity studies have been carried out previously for a few planar silicon geometries, data on humidity effects upon the 3D geometry are not in the literature. Our study shows that breakdown correlates with humidity and manifests at edges and surfaces not directly correlated with electrodes. Haley presented this, her honors thesis result, at a seminar at UNM in May 2014. Martin is preparing an electrostatic simulation to validate the results.

Technologies for use at future colliders including ILC

Martin and Neil are developing an ultra-low-mass interconnect for use in future colliders. This design (not the same as the one described in the ATLAS Upgrade section above) must have ultra-low mass because the cable will attach directly on top of its sensor (this is not typically done) and maintain constant impedance over 2 meters, a challenge for flex technology. Haley and Neil populated several prototypes that are now being assembled with sensors and electronics by our collaborators at SLAC and U.C. Davis.

Aaron collaborated with UCSC on a paper on microstrip electrode readout noise that was published in 2013. The team studied an application appropriate to cases for which beam-delivery and detector-occupancy characteristics permit a long shaping-time readout of long daisy-chained ladders of fine-pitch sensors read out by a single front-end amplifier. They found that network effects significantly mitigate the amount of readout noise contributed by the detector load.

A new charge collection model for future tracking detectors

Igor is a member of the ATLAS Large Eta Task Force, which is predicting the physics gains possible during Phase-II (year 2022 and beyond) of improved detector performance at pseudorapidities in the range 2.5 to 5. There is potential for significantly increased acceptance in over a dozen processes of high interest, including H → 4μ and vector boson fusion jets from HWW events. The ITK simulation is central to the effort, as extended tracking coverage is the primary driver for everything outside the tracker. Thus Igor's objective is development of a charge collection model for ITK including this possible expansion. The model will describe the charge generated due to energy loss (dE/dx) along the track path in the sensor's depleted volume. Igor is incorporating into the model effects including (1) impact of Lorentz angle on charge drift, (2) position smearing due to a thermal diffusion, (3) noise on top of the charge signal, (4) cross-talk induced from other pixels, and (5) radiation damage effects including partial depletion, charge trapping, and increased shot noise, leading to hit efficiency degradation. To simulate a time-over-threshold measurement, a time stamp for each pixel above threshold is computed, taking into account charge-dependent timewalk and trigger-dependent offsets. The unprecedented pile-up and radiation in the Phase-II era renders earlier models insufficient.

In 2015, Igor will be developing the baseline charge model and leading a small team implementing it into the ITK simulation software. He will use this software to analyze detector performance for a spectrum of configurations of pixel pitch, sensor thickness, and so forth. He will play a leading role at the test beam runs to collect the experimental data needed for the model development. By 2016, Igor will be extending and refining the model through comparisons to his beam test l data. In 2017 he will finalize the radiation damage factors and lead the preparation of this portion of the ITK TDR. Year 2018 will bring the start of pixel pre-production with associated effort by Igor on beam tests and further simulation to optimize engineering and cost questions. While this will surely benefit ATLAS, the effort on the charge model is sufficiently general to be applied to other future tracker applications as well. The effort will require half of his time throughout 2015-19.

As of 2014

Completed Works

  • We measured the breakdown characteristics of 3D silicon sensors after exposing them to non-uniform radiation fields. Martin and Rui collaborated with Sherwood Parker to optimize the redesign of sensors to be used at the innermost layers of ATLAS. They published this in September 2012.
  • We measured the resistivity of polycrystalline diamond sensors as a function of temperature and charged particle fluence. This study by Rui, Martin, and Sally has just been published by NIM. Any effect of radiation on the resistivity of diamond propagates to the leakage current and could then influence assessments of the material properties that depend on leakage current measurement, such as active volume and charge collection distance. Rui reported on this work at several meetings of the RD42 Collaboration this year.

Ongoing Works

  • We developed a new method for real time measurement of charged particle beam profile and fluence. This technique was pioneered by Martin and implemented by Aaron (in software) and Prabi, Haley, and Qufei in hardware. It has recently been published in NIM (see above). Aaron described it in his talk at DPF 2013. Neil is updating the configuration to allow simultaneous readout of multiple stations at different points in the stack of devices under test.
  • Comparative studies of charge collection and electrical breakdown in 3D sensors with three technology options are in progress. Haley, Sally, and Martin are collaborating with Gian-Franco Dalla Betta of the University of Padova on devices that could be used in numerous high radiation field applications. Martin and Sally reported first results on this at the 8th Trento Workshop. Haley described her contribution at the 2013 New Mexico Shared Knowledge Conference. This will be the subject of Haley's 2014 B.S. Honors thesis in Physics. She plans to convert the thesis into a NIM article during summer 2014.
  • We lead a joint ATLAS-CMS radiation damage program at LANSCE, Los Alamos. This activity is led by Sally and Martin and involves all members of our group in biannual testbeam operations. It is followed by dosimetry and activation measurements, and detailed studies of radiation-induced modifications to device characteristics. The runs in September 2012, December 2012, September 2013, and (anticipated) December 2013 each involve approximately 100 unique prototypes. Devices include, for example, many technology variations of silicon and diamond sensors, readout electronics chips and custom ASICs, VCSEL drivers, monolithic active pixel sensors, power supply switching elements, specialized cables, miniaturized peltier coolers, components of the AFP light collectors and timing circuit, and upgrade calorimetry elements. This year Haley and Martin added a customized system for providing airflow cooling to silicon sensors undergoing temperature-critical annealing studies. Neil leads the dosimetry program and is developing the December 2013 run plan. We all take shifts and participate in device fixturing, assembly, and measurements.
    A description of the LANSCE beam profile is here.

  • Coordination of on-demand joint ATLAS-CMS irradiations at the Sandia Annular Core Research Reactor and Gamma Irradiation Facility. This program was spearheaded by Sally and involved lengthy development of an Inter-institutional Visitors Agreement between Sandia and UNM. The list of technologies irradiated is similar to the above.
  • Development of a low mass interconnect for use with the SiD vertex tracker, known as a "pigtail". Martin is designing these devices (pigtail plus extension cable) for use in beam tests in winter 2013/14. The primary challenge for the pigtail comes from the fact that it is required to fit on top of the sensor (this has not been done before) and thus must have extremely low mass to minimize particle scatters. The challenge for the extension cable is maintaining constant impedance over a 2-meter length, not typical for flex technology. Haley is populating the pigtails, and Neil will carry out the connectivity tests. Sally reported on this activity at the January 2013 SiD Workshop.
  • We are studying annealing in highly irradiated p-type and n-type float zone and magnetic Czochralski silicon substrates and predicting related detector operational lifetime at the HL-LHC. This study was initiated by Jessica Metcalfe and is being finalized by Sally and Igor.
  • Martin is developing the calibration pulser for the ATLAS AFP subsystem, based on a Kapustinsky circuit.
  • As members of the newly formed RD-53 collaboration for development of future (65nm) pixel chips for LHC experiments, we are responsible for transistor testing (Martin and Neil) and irradiation (all).
  • We have several responsibilities to the ATLAS pixel module upgrade. In spring 2013 Martin conducted a series of electrical and mechanical measurements of upgrade modules with flex cables, in collaboration with INFN Genova. He is now collaborating with UCSC and SLAC to identify or design radiation hard pico-coaxial cables for the upgrade era. Martin's work was reported in the talk, "Microcoax and picocoax cables," on 7 November 2013 during ATLAS Upgrade Week.